20.8% of Motors have Resistance Imbalances above 3.76%
Why is this so important here’s what DeepSeek response states which I totally agree with.
Excellent question. A voltage drop to one winding of an electric motor from a Resistive defect is a serious and damaging condition. It fundamentally unbalances the motor's operation and leads to a cascade of negative effects.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the consequences, from the electrical and magnetic effects to the physical damage and system-wide impact.
The Root Cause: The "Single-Phasing" Effect
A significant voltage drop in one winding effectively creates a condition very similar to single-phasing, where one phase is completely lost. While not as severe as a complete loss, a severe voltage drop has the same destructive nature.
1. Immediate Electrical & Magnetic Consequences
- Unbalanced Magnetic Fields: A three-phase motor is designed to have three, 120-degree separated, equal-strength magnetic fields that create a perfectly rotating magnetic field. A voltage drop in one winding creates a weaker magnetic field in that phase. This results in an elliptical and wobbly rotating field instead of a smooth, rotating one.
- Increased Current in the Healthy Windings: To try to overcome the imbalance and deliver the power the load demands, the motor will draw more current. The current in the two healthy windings can increase to 1.5 to 2 times the normal full-load current.
- Circulating Currents: The unbalanced voltages cause negative-sequence currents to flow within the rotor. These currents rotate in the opposite direction to the rotor's rotation, inducing double-frequency currents in the rotor bars and causing excessive heating. Circulating Currents are a leading cause of Bearing Fluting or EDM.
2. Thermal Consequences (The Primary Killer)
The increased current leads to severe overheating:
- Hot Spot in the Weakened Winding: Ironically, the winding with the low voltage can often overheat first. This is because, despite the lower voltage, the current in this phase does not decrease proportionally due to the motor's attempt to maintain torque. The reduced cooling effect (from lower air flow due to the unbalanced magnetic field) can cause a hot spot in this winding.
- General Overheating: The two healthy windings are now carrying significantly higher current than designed, causing them to overheat rapidly.
- Insulation Breakdown: Motor insulation is rated for specific temperatures (e.g., Class B: 130°C). The excessive heat degrades the insulation, making it brittle and eventually causing it to fail. This results in short circuits between turns (turn-to-turn fault) or to the ground, leading to a complete motor burnout.
3. Mechanical and Performance Consequences
- Reduced Torque and Power: The motor will struggle to produce its rated torque. This leads to: Difficulty Starting: The motor may not be able to start at all, simply humming and drawing locked-rotor current until a protective device trips.Reduced Speed: Under load, the motor's speed will drop, and it may stall.
- Difficulty Starting: The motor may not be able to start at all, simply humming and drawing locked-rotor current until a protective device trips.
- Reduced Speed: Under load, the motor's speed will drop, and it may stall.
- Increased Noise and Vibration: The unbalanced magnetic forces cause the stator and rotor to experience pulsating torques, leading to severe vibration and a distinctive "rumbling" or "growling" sound. This is a classic audible sign of single-phasing or severe voltage unbalance.
- Bearing Damage: The excessive vibration accelerates wear in the motor's bearings, leading to premature failure. The increased heat also degrades the bearing grease, further shortening bearing life.
4. System-Wide Consequences
- Nuisance Tripping: Protective devices like overload relays and circuit breakers may trip due to the high current draw, causing unexpected downtime.
- Drive Train Damage: The severe vibrations can damage connected equipment like couplings, pulleys, belts, gears, and the driven load (e.g., a pump or compressor).
- Higher Energy Costs: The motor operates inefficiently, drawing more current to do less work, which increases electricity consumption.
Quantifying the Damage: The Voltage Unbalance Rule of Thumb
A well-known rule in the industry highlights how sensitive motors are to voltage unbalance:
A 1% voltage unbalance can cause a 6-10% increase in motor temperature rise.
This means that even a small unbalance, which might seem insignificant, can have a dramatically large thermal effect and significantly shorten the motor's lifespan.
Summary of Failure Progression
- Voltage Drop Occurs in one phase due to a faulty connection, unbalanced supply, or network issue.
- Current increases dramatically in the two healthy phases.
- Motor temperature soars, creating hot spots.
- Insulation begins to degrade and carbonize.
- Vibration and noise increase, damaging bearings and mechanical parts.
- Insulation fails, causing a short circuit and motor burnout.
Key Findings & Interpretation
- Strong Right Skew: The data is heavily skewed to the right, evidenced by: Mean (7.33) >> Median (0.44)Standard Deviation (16.96) is more than double the meanThis indicates that while most values are very low, a few extremely high values are pulling the average upward.
- Mean (7.33) >> Median (0.44)
- Standard Deviation (16.96) is more than double the mean
- This indicates that while most values are very low, a few extremely high values are pulling the average upward.
- Typical Healthy Operation: The median value is 0.44, meaning half of all motors have a resistance imbalance of 0.44 or less.The 75th percentile is 1.58, meaning 75% of motors are at or below this very low level of imbalance.This suggests the majority of equipment is in good electrical condition.
- The median value is 0.44, meaning half of all motors have a resistance imbalance of 0.44 or less.
- The 75th percentile is 1.58, meaning 75% of motors are at or below this very low level of imbalance.
- This suggests the majority of equipment is in good electrical condition.
- Outlier Detection: Upper Bound = Q3 + 1.5×IQR = 1.58 + (1.5 × 1.45) = 3.76Any value > 3.76 is considered a statistical outlier.Number of Outliers: 194 records (~20.8% of the data)These outliers represent equipment that requires immediate attention, as high resistance imbalance can indicate winding faults, loose connections, or other serious issues.
- Upper Bound = Q3 + 1.5×IQR = 1.58 + (1.5 × 1.45) = 3.76
- Any value > 3.76 is considered a statistical outlier.
- Number of Outliers: 194 records (~20.8% of the data)
- These outliers represent equipment that requires immediate attention, as high resistance imbalance can indicate winding faults, loose connections, or other serious issues.
All TestPro Motor Analyzer Warning Level is 3% Just below the Statistical Outliers of 3.76%.
Blog Free Advice on Electric Motor Reliability and Energy Savings
Feel free to Copy Link and use on your Website (Blue Chain Button)- MENU ABOVE
Gain Electric Motor Reliability & Return Energy Savings


